Sorry, I don't have specific plays documented. However, I did look at every play, as I stated previously, frame by frame. We've discussed strengths and weaknesses at great length. At this point, I dont know what else to say, other than what I already have.

 

SIDE NOTE: See my comments on the TO post again and you'll find my reasons for him not making it were talent related.

 

As usual, it turns into an agree to disagree situation. C'est la vie. I just wish you could speak specifics so that I knew where we differed on opinion. Because, to be quite frank, I honestly don't see how someone could grade every play and still come to the conclusion that Webb beat out Williams.

As usual, it turns into an agree to disagree situation. C'est la vie. I just wish you could speak specifics so that I knew where we differed on opinion. Because, to be quite frank, I honestly don't see how someone could grade every play and still come to the conclusion that Webb beat out Williams.

Jason this is not to get in the middle of you and Mongo I just want to know that when you are breaking down the film (game) that your wife bust your chops about is it the regular broadcast or is it the coaches film?

 

I personally thought in the Browns game watching the Bears Network broadcast on Fox here in Chicago that the back ups looked much better than the first string line sans Williams at OC. Henry at OG ,Brown and Brandon at OT looked like they all were worthy of a roster spot and since the rumor has it that they may keep 4 TEs an undrafted rookie is just as good to help as Webb or Williams. Since I can only watch the BN broadcast and I am usually slleepy while doing it during the preseason, I generally wait for a rebroadcast on the BN or NFL Network before I form my opinion. So really what I'm saying is I agree with you that neither guy has outplayed the other and what everyone else is saying is that who sucked less.

 

Lets all face it they both sucked.

Jason this is not to get in the middle of you and Mongo I just want to know that when you are breaking down the film (game) that your wife bust your chops about is it the regular broadcast or is it the coaches film?

 

I personally thought in the Browns game watching the Bears Network broadcast on Fox here in Chicago that the back ups looked much better than the first string line sans Williams at OC. Henry at OG ,Brown and Brandon at OT looked like they all were worthy of a roster spot and since the rumor has it that they may keep 4 TEs an undrafted rookie is just as good to help as Webb or Williams. Since I can only watch the BN broadcast and I am usually slleepy while doing it during the preseason, I generally wait for a rebroadcast on the BN or NFL Network before I form my opinion. So really what I'm saying is I agree with you that neither guy has outplayed the other and what everyone else is saying is that who sucked less.

 

Lets all face it they both sucked.

 

Just regular game broadcast. I wish I had access to more than that. I usually watch whatever reply is on the NFL network as well, but it's pretty much the same thing + a few more angles from time to time.