You know I have my issues with Smith, but I can easily see why is is appreciated.
The players do love him. It's rare for him to call anyone out in public. One the rare occasion he does, it usually motivates or is a pre-cursor to a pink slp for the player.
The owners love him because he's good enough to get into the playoffs with some regularity, is a nice guy, and realize the players play for him.
The coaches probably like him because he doesn't throw anyone under the bus.
All this is on the surface for the most part. he basically circles the wagons and says jack. Similar to Billichick. Except Lovie comes off a little better dressed. He' irritating to fans and media. But, for those in the inside, I can see where he's very appreciated. He keeps his cards close to his vest. We fans and media don't like it, but I'll bet management and players do.
Over the years, I've changed from disliking Smith more than JA to now hating JA more. Smith appears to be learning a bit. I wish he could force adjustments more mid-game for one. But I've seen inprovements. He no longer has DB's 20 yards off the LOS on every play. There is some hope he could get better with a staff that is complimentary (Tice? "Run fisrt") and a GM that can get him some damn talent.
My glass is half on him. Not full nor empty. Just 1/2. Whereas my glass on JA is bone freaking dry with residue of rat poison.