Stinger226

We agree on something, if Poles makes the wrong decision, he will end up losing his job over it. I will trust him to make the best decision. I dont need to be right to be happy with any decision but you will freak out if he doesnt take a top 10 pick QB, thats the difference between us. Have your opinion, stay a Bear fan and hope he made the right choice for the future of the Bears even if he keeps Fields.

I say only Poles opinion is all that matters and you say it means( I say no one else can have an opinion.) It amazes me how all you want to do is turn everything in to a conflict. I never said ( you're not respecting my opinion), i always say everyone has a right to have dfferent opinions. You say ,( you can only argue if you defend your opinion) there again , that's not necessary to give an opinion, you dont make the rules. How do I know who she talked to? She states it in the video, she never talked to any GMs, other people. When I post other peoples opinions( former players, former QBs, media that wants to keep Justin), you blow them off because they dont agree with you, yet the people Carmen talked to are important opinions. Up until Poles makes this decision, it is going to be a highly debated argument. I have always given you credit for a well thought out opinion yet you keep fighting with anyone who disagrees with you. There is only good and bad choices, there is no right or wrong opinions. We wont know what was the right choice until next year is played.

Of course everything you post is all about being right. This is just another opinion of a( not important fan), just like us. People have different opinions on Justin , they are allowed to do that, they dont need to prove why they think he will be back. I post different opinions and yet you think 90% of everyone thinks like you. You post information as to why we should move on from Justin, the majority of stats suggest that's the best choice but if Poles thinks he can be better , it doesnt matter if its a bad choice, he will still do what he thinks is best. With all you complained about with Flus , Poles brought him back because HE thought it was his best choice. IF he brings Justin back and gets a draft capital bonanza, it doesnt have to be his best choice, only what he wants to do. Tell everyone how stupid he is, it means nothing. No matter what choices he makes we wont know if he is right until November of this year. Have fun posting.

https://x.com/BC2__/status/1753934109125054630?s=20

That's Carmen Vitale or something like that. People have been saying Cronin. Other GMs opinions may count but most she talks to carries no weight. Poles knows what's best and if he runs back with Fields, screw everyone's else opinion. Its his show to run. He not doing a popularity contest.

Thats all you're going to get unless some team wants to move past Washington and raises the stakes. No way they would throw in McLaurian.

Found it interesting that Kingsbury is now being considered for the Washington OC job. Are the ducks lining up for Williams in Washington. Interesting.

Here is onbe for the defense.

Here is a video giving a realitic view of our 2024 roster. offense

Seen where 4 of the 6 new HCs hired are defensive minded coaches. I guess it was just fans that think new hires have to bo offensive minded coaches, the NFL brass seem to disagree.

For good or bad if Poles rolls back with Justin, the traded first pick will be a better haul than last yr and is part of the transaction. If he can trade back a couple of times, he could add 6 blue chip players and may still get MHJ or Bowers. One of them could be a QB not named Maye or Williams.

Totally agree, she uses common sense as a tool.

I agree Washington would be a worst situation than coming here but Colin says its viewed as a coach staying longer where as he views Flus as a lameduck coach and have a new system in two years. One spot could get you a decent return, when Pace traded for Tribisky, he gave up a first second and fourth in the first year and a third the next year. Williams is considered a better get so you could get more plus the stakes it raises if other teams want that pick. Washington would have to fork up a 1 first, a second, a fouth this year and first next year and a player. Ricky Stromberg/ a second year OC/OG , Jahan Dotbson/WR, a former 1st round pick , Deron Payne would be the prize but very expensive contract.

I think they bring in a vet (Aaron Brewer) played under the assiant line coach or Evan Brown who played under Shane Waldron and draft a mid round center. Not sure it matters but Poles drafted Doug Kramer or signed for next year Dan Feeney, if one of them may be the vet backup or maybe even a starter until a rookie takes over.

Colin on his show two days ago stated that Caleb doesn't want to go Chicago. He thinks they screwed over Justin Fields and have a lame duck coach. The Williams camp walked back on that yesterday , they don't want to be looked like the villain but they never denied saying it. A few months ago he said he would only play for a few teams and wanted a piece of the franchise. Chicago wasnt on that list. Caleb wants to go to Washington, he grew up in the DC area, that makes sense. They have a new coach and feel that he will be there for four years and will have a more stable future there. Colin was on the Score yesterday and talked about this. Colin is friends with Riley and have been on the sidelines for several USC games. He has met Caleb's father and Caleb many times, so he's not just blowing smoke when he makes statements. Caleb's father is involved in the process and a lot of the comments come from him. He wants him in Washington which have the second pick. That makes some sense, the kid was a long time Redskins fan. It's hard to distinguish what is real and not real but at least Colin has some insight being he's been involved with the family before. Joe Burrows was from Ohio and wanted to play for the Bengals, he got his wish. From all this talk the one thing you can determine is , him and his dad have a big egos and they will try to throw their weight around to influence where Caleb goes, Washington picks second.

I have seen her on many videos, her opinions are all over the place.

( the dumbest thing i ever heard) What's silly is you can't live in peace, you constantly poke the bear and then turn around and pretend you're the innocent one. Grow up

What was the trades? 9 to what to what?

Let's leave out the fact he improved this year, and will get better. For you speechless wouldn't be so bad. Reading is a skill, you misinterpret( not a great passer) like it means he can't pass but you do that all the time so nothing new there.

I wouldn't doubt Philly takes him with Kelce retiring. Kill, you like Frazier better or Van Pran, not sure if I got the name right.

He's probably doing that at every city in top 5. He's originally from Washington DC. Lots of players like going home.

When people disagree on subjects it doesn't mean they think your argument is trash, it's just seeing different criteria for their side of a conversation. You could just like Justin, not necessarily try to put up a legitimate argument I'm never tried to say Justin is a great passer, that isn't even an argument, its about other things he brings to the table and whether the can get better with other coaches or better weapons. That's opinions, it's easy to say odds are against it, that's true but if history shows it possible , it's OK to think that .. It's not cool to say that your opinion is trash, just because it's not the same as yours but you can say it, no one here is stopping that.

Agree with all that, the point with Young is the experts said he was the best QB, not that is was the same as Williams by comparison.

Thanks

Does anyone know who we added that came from this game? I think Bagent and Tyler Scott were there but not familiar with anyone else.