Stinger226

I think Maye probably is farther down the list. He had a great junior year but his senior season had a lot of stinkers in it. Daniels only had one great year , other years were not special. MT only had one very good year of which a lot of college QBs do . It comes down to risk factor, CW is the only one with special put on him. It will come down to character issues if Poles doesnt take him, he not taking a QB just for sake of change. The OTs are rated high and deserve to be but dont think they will be on Poles list. Braxton got better last year, had many penalties but only gave up two sacks. Dont think he goes there with so many other special players rated high. I think the rest of the list is spot on. I think he picks weapons or DL with his high picks after he figures out the QB question. S and OC will come later after the first round.

I agree with that but some experts claimed him to be the best of the year, not special but it just shows you , they make bad judgements and the only evaluation that matters is the one Poles does.

I seen a writer say that Waldron run a lot of two TE sets in Seattle. Two TEs would give us the middle of the field, a place the Bears didn't throw a lot last year. Helps in the run game. With DJ and a big WR , you create havoc.

I throw up just looking at a bottle of Gin.

Lots of rumors this time of year. Journalists like to project.

True good QBs get on teams that are running teams first, it screws up thier stats.

He will take him but he has several options with that pick. It all has to do with his evaluation process, if he passes the character test, yes. If there's any questions he may view a haul of draft capital as the better choice. Its not a given that he's the generaltional QB, experts get QBs wrong all the time . The year Mahomes got drafted, no one thought he was that, and the experts from ESPN said DeShone Kizer was the dude. Its difficult to find NFL QBs.

Option with just one trade and get MHJ, good option.

If Williams ends up being the dude, you are getting massive offers for the #1 pick. If its Washington, there exists the possibility of another trade down for #2. So many teams need QBs, there may be another trade back. Multi 1 st rounds future pcks, multi 2nd round picks this year plus maybe getting players back. The question, does anyone think Poles passes up that kind of team building haul from someone that wants to build thru the draft. I know, do you?

If we end up getting 8 top 100 players in this draft, shit is hitting the fan in the division next year. We can only dream.

I read an article where Caleb Williams actually said he was better than Mahomes. It was right after he won the Hiesman Trophy. The reason Mahomes got great was having a coach that developed him and a great team around him, PLUS his talent. If he was drafted by the Bears he would have never become the best QB in the league. I think Poles is one year away from building a team to have a plug and play QB the same situation SF put Purdy in. What might be bizziare is Bagent might turn into Purdy with a couple of years of development , wouldnt that be the bomb while we argue over other QBs.

North Carolina carries a notion , the QBs coming from there never suceed in the NFL. Its the same stigma that the Bears cant develop QBs. Its like OL lineman are always good from, Michigan and Ohio State. TEs from Iowa They all have some truths to them but nothing is absolute.

Spot on, what will drive that kind of return will be other teams wanting the pick.

Great idea, don't go anywhere. Everyone knows how I feel, I don't need to stick up for Justin anymore, a lot of members of the media do that for me. So until after free agency, no need to get involved in QB discussions anymore. I'm getting ready to go to Thailand, but ill still try to get the bears big board concept initiated.

i think we will be a winning team this year but agree we are a year away from contending for a SB, if that was your intention.

It will be killer ( no pun intended) if we end up with Bowers,JPJ, Corley, dont know enough about the rest of the picks but i will. (minus picking a QB)

They all could end up being good or a late round pick could surprize people. Kelce was a 5th round pick and took a few years to develop. To me JPJ may be the best rookie if needed to be a starter early.

I totally agree with all of that, there is no wrong decision , one may have better results than the other one but both can still allow us to be a winning team in 2024.

You are the most grounded person on this site , I dont always agree with you but I never attack you for it. I too, like to post both sides of a topic, of course I lean one way or another but always leave both options open. You can be wrong about facts, mis quote someone, but opinions dont have a right or wrong answer. This site is about dicussiong the Bears, it never has to get personal.

I agree with you, I just post information for and against keeping Fields, I post on prospects ,on mock drafts, other peoples information but I have no intert in fighting with anyone. .That is not my agenda, I dont care if Im right or wrong, if doesnt matter if no one agrees with me. Its just being a Bears fan. If my posts annoy anyone, stop reading them , poeple dont need to get personal because they dont agree with me. I do repond when people bad mouth me, thats not going to change. I am not going to quit posting , none of it is done for sake of fighting. So i apologize to anyone that doesnt like this, I dont like it either.

We agree on something, if Poles makes the wrong decision, he will end up losing his job over it. I will trust him to make the best decision. I dont need to be right to be happy with any decision but you will freak out if he doesnt take a top 10 pick QB, thats the difference between us. Have your opinion, stay a Bear fan and hope he made the right choice for the future of the Bears even if he keeps Fields.

I say only Poles opinion is all that matters and you say it means( I say no one else can have an opinion.) It amazes me how all you want to do is turn everything in to a conflict. I never said ( you're not respecting my opinion), i always say everyone has a right to have dfferent opinions. You say ,( you can only argue if you defend your opinion) there again , that's not necessary to give an opinion, you dont make the rules. How do I know who she talked to? She states it in the video, she never talked to any GMs, other people. When I post other peoples opinions( former players, former QBs, media that wants to keep Justin), you blow them off because they dont agree with you, yet the people Carmen talked to are important opinions. Up until Poles makes this decision, it is going to be a highly debated argument. I have always given you credit for a well thought out opinion yet you keep fighting with anyone who disagrees with you. There is only good and bad choices, there is no right or wrong opinions. We wont know what was the right choice until next year is played.

Of course everything you post is all about being right. This is just another opinion of a( not important fan), just like us. People have different opinions on Justin , they are allowed to do that, they dont need to prove why they think he will be back. I post different opinions and yet you think 90% of everyone thinks like you. You post information as to why we should move on from Justin, the majority of stats suggest that's the best choice but if Poles thinks he can be better , it doesnt matter if its a bad choice, he will still do what he thinks is best. With all you complained about with Flus , Poles brought him back because HE thought it was his best choice. IF he brings Justin back and gets a draft capital bonanza, it doesnt have to be his best choice, only what he wants to do. Tell everyone how stupid he is, it means nothing. No matter what choices he makes we wont know if he is right until November of this year. Have fun posting.

https://x.com/BC2__/status/1753934109125054630?s=20